Be Careful What You Wish For...

I was watching this YouTube clip of Ann Coulter being interviewed on MSNBC.
The host asks her what her ideal vision of America would be. She says everyone would be Christian.
He attacks her for being anti-semitic. Unfortunately, her line of argument was that Christianity was the perfection of Judaism. It wasn't the finest of arguments, and it was clear that she really hadn't anticipated the line of questioning to which she would be subjected.
What I find unfortunate, however, is that the host insinuates that it is somehow hateful and ignorant to want everyone to be the same faith...in an ideal state.
It was rather like asking someone: "If you could create the ideal dessert, what would it be?" And then berating the person for being a glutton who had no concerns about obesity: "You would want what for dessert?!? That's absurd? That would make you fat."
He asked a question that disregarded practical issues, and then derided her for not giving a practical answer.